”You don't see yourself very clearly, you know.”: En komparativ karaktärsanalys av Isabella Swan i Stephenie Meyers Twilight (2005) och Midnight Sun (2020)
2026 (Swedish)Independent thesis Basic level (degree of Bachelor), 10 credits / 15 HE credits
Student thesis
Abstract [en]
The intent of this study was to examine how an unreliable narrator and different internal focalization points in a narrative may obscure or reinforce the description of the character Isabella Swan in Stephenie Meyer’s Twilight (2005) and Midnight Sun (2020). The novels follow the same sequence of events but told by separate narrators and focalizers; in Twilight it is Isabella Swan and in Midnight Sun it is Edward Cullen. With this narrative structure, it is possible to analyse scenes, actions, character motivations and descriptions from more than one point of view. This is something that can entail a deeper understanding of a character. As Twilight has faced critique regarding stereotypical gender roles, uneven power-dynamics, conservative social values, as well as a flat main character – Bella – a comparative character analyses may be in order to reevaluate her literary composition.
In Twilight, Bella comes across as a socially awkward, clumsy and observant teenage girl. She tends to suppress her own needs, she acts more maturely, despite being a teenager, and she’s very self-critical. Once Bella befriends Edward, she becomes more cheerful and her bravery shines through whenever she’s put in danger, which happens more than once, due to vampires. In Midnight Sun, Bella is first strongly disliked by Edward due to her tempting blood. But gradually, he finds her company very pleasing and her silent mind gives him a welcoming peace. An idealized picture of her comes forth. Edward views her as selfless, caring and pure. But she is also very breakable due to her humanity, a stark contrast to the vampires’ supernatural abilities. Also, he often views Bella as a puzzle for him to solve as he can’t read her mind. Bella’s clumsiness is also very present.
In short, the narrative structure in Twilight does paint a less favourable picture of Bella. In her own eyes, she is plain and boring while Edward is certain of her importance. In Midnight Sun, through Edward’s focalization, the construct of Bella deepens which is well needed due to Twilight’s more narrowed narrative. In short, the narrator’s self-image is very relevant.
Place, publisher, year, edition, pages
2026. , p. 47
Keywords [en]
Twilight (2005), Midnight Sun (2020), Character analysis, Focalization, Power-critical perspective, Gender
National Category
General Literature Studies
Identifiers
URN: urn:nbn:se:miun:diva-59023OAI: oai:DiVA.org:miun-59023DiVA, id: diva2:2115320
Subject / course
Comparative Literature LV1
Educational program
Literature and Writing HLISG 180 credits
Supervisors
Examiners
Note
Slutgiltigt godkännandedatum: 2026-08-27
2026-11-042026-11-04